Are Seer Stones Just 19th-Century Folk Magic? (Live)

Episode 60 • November 15, 2026 • 00:41:44
Are Seer Stones Just 19th-Century Folk Magic? (Live)
Informed Saints
Are Seer Stones Just 19th-Century Folk Magic? (Live)

Nov 15 2026 | 00:41:44

/

Show Notes

Mark Twain called the Book of Mormon "chloroform in print." Seer stones get mocked as 19th-century folk magic. Live on stage, we push back on both, with help from the best papers at this year's Book of Mormon Culture Conference.

Recorded live at the closing session of the 2026 Book of Mormon Culture Conference in Provo, Jasmin Rappleye, Neal Rappleye and Dr. Stephen Smoot talk through the papers, art and music that moved them most.

All the conference presentations will be live within days at https://bomal.org/archive, where each presentation will have its own embedded video.

Chapters

0:00 Live at the Book of Mormon Culture Conference

1:54 Art & music: Mark Twain was wrong

4:11 Chiasmus and the music of the text

6:09 Book of Mormon art we love

8:06 The tree of life and the virgin (1 Nephi 11)

10:27 Testaments, Emma Earle and consecration

14:14 Are seer stones 19th-century folk magic?

16:53 Stone boxes in Santiago Atitlán

19:09 The 1826 trial and divination in the Bible

21:33 Is the Book of Mormon anti-Deuteronomy?

23:35 Deuteronomy all through the Book of Mormon

28:08 Zion theology vs. the Deuteronomists

30:33 Nephite timekeeping

33:13 Lamanite women and queens

36:31 The future of Book of Mormon studies

41:19 Study deeply, believe boldly

===Sources & Further Reading===

- Conference papers by Kerry Hull & Michael J. Biggerstaff (seers and seer stones), Allen Hansen (Deuteronomy), Scott V. Brian (timekeeping), Julie Frederick (Lamanite women) and Rosalynde F. Welch (keynote):

https://bomal.org/archive

- Grant Hardy, ed., The Annotated Book of Mormon (Oxford University Press, 2023), 867–68

- Neal Rappleye, "The Deuteronomist Reforms and Lehi's Family Dynamics: A Social Context for the Rebellions of Laman and Lemuel," Interpreter 16 (2015): 87–99:

https://interpreterfoundation.org/journal/the-deuteronomist-reforms-and-lehis-family-dynamics-a-social-context-for-the-rebellions-of-laman-and-lemuel

- Allen J. Christenson, Art and Society in a Highland Maya Community: The Altarpiece of Santiago Atitlán (University of Texas Press, 2001), 50

- Taylor Halverson, "Deuteronomy 17:14–20 as Criteria for Book of Mormon Kingship," Interpreter 24 (2017):

https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/interpreter/vol24/iss1/4

- Neal Rappleye, "'The Time Is Past': A Note on Samuel's Five-Year Prophecy," Interpreter 29 (2018):

https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/interpreter/vol29/iss1/5/

- Daniel C. Peterson, "Nephi and His Asherah," Journal of Book of Mormon Studies 9/2 (2000):

https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/jbms/vol9/iss2/4

===Art & Media Credits===

Event photos: Justin Hackworth, official photographer of the Book of Mormon Culture Conference: https://justinhackworth.com

Presenter slides courtesy of the Book of Mormon Arts & Letters Foundation: Paul Anderson, Kerry Hull, Michael J. Biggerstaff, Allen Hansen, Scott V. Brian, Julie Frederick, Rosalynde F. Welch. Also a slide from Neal Rappleye's 2026 FAIR Conference presentation.

Walter Rane, One by One (courtesy of the Book of Mormon Arts & Letters Foundation)

Jorge Cocco Santángelo, Nephi and the Liahona, Christ and the Twelve Disciples in America, Moroni and the Last Pages, The Prophecies of Samuel: https://bookofmormonartcatalog.org/artists/cocco-jorge/

Caleb Williams (Library of Godwin), The Gospel Brought to the World and The Veil Parted: https://bookofmormonartcatalog.org/artists/williams-caleb/

Ahmed Jamal Qureshi, Tanaazul Allah (The Condescension of God), Church History Museum 13th International Art Competition: https://history.churchofjesuschrist.org/museum/artcompetition/visitorchoice/entries/b8340d0a-8d0f-ef11-9899-000d3a02a895

Amberlea Erekson Smoot, Earnestly Contend for the Faith and I Will Show You All These: https://amberlea.myportfolio.com/

Also shown: Jacob Whitmer's seer stone (a Native American gorget); Albrecht Dürer, Knight, Death and the Devil (The Met, CC0); Gustave Doré, Ezekiel Prophesying (public domain); the Great Isaiah Scroll (public domain); Iglesia de Santiago Apóstol, Santiago Atitlán, photo by Hans Birger Nilsen (CC BY-SA 2.0); map data: Natural Earth.

Thanks to the Book of Mormon Culture Conference for hosting us.

Study deeply, believe boldly.

===Informed Saints Credits===

Produced by The Ancient America Foundation

Producer: Spencer Clark

Hosts: Stephen Smoot, Neal Rappleye, Jasmin Rappleye

===Discover===

If any of our thoughts resonated with you, consider learning more about the single most influential book in our lives.

https://www.discoverbookofmormon.org/

===Content Disclaimer===

The views expressed represent ours alone and do not necessarily reflect the official position of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

#BookOfMormon #InformedSaints #LDS #LatterDaySaints #SeerStones #BookOfMormonEvidence #Deuteronomy #LamaniteWomen #BookOfMormonArt #StephenSmoot #NealRappleye #JasminRappleye

Chapters

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:00] Speaker A: So please join me in welcoming the Informed Saints podcast. [00:00:09] Speaker B: All right, well, we are thrilled to be here at the Book of Mormon Culture Conference. I've been looking forward to this conference for months. Last year was fantastic. This year, great. And at Informed Saints, we exist because we want to help build informed testimonies. We're passionate about scholarship and studying the gospel deeply, but not being ashamed of the gospel of Jesus Christ and building a testimony that can withstand scrutiny, that can withstand criticism. And so for today, we are talking about the Book of Mormon. But in this capacity, we're not really, like, posing as scholars or artists or musicians. We are your Statler and Waldorf muppets, like Peanut Gallery. We're reflecting on how amazing this conference has been and just giving some perspectives from, I guess, our podcaster's point of view. So one thing that Neil always says that I have loved is that the Book of Mormon is miraculous, beautiful, and true. And it's all of these things because at Informed Saints, we. We tend to focus a lot on the true part. We love the scholarship, and we love, like, evidence for the Book of Mormon, the authenticity of the Book of Mormon and showing how it can be robust. But we also understand that a study of the Book of Mormon is incomplete if you're not also appreciating that miraculous and that beautiful part. And that's what we love about the Book of Mormon Culture Conference, is that there's a lot of beautiful, meaty scholarship here, but we also appreciate the art, the music, the sophistication of this text. And so, yeah, so we're gonna talk about all the things we loved about this conference, and we'll just probably pick a couple talks that we're gonna highlight and reflect on, and then maybe a little bit of Q and A at the end, depending on what time it is. So I'll go ahead and start off, because I was very pleasantly surprised at how much I loved the music session. I'm gonna start off with a quote from Mark Twain, who famously said that the Book of Mormon, chloroform in print. This is, you know, a literary giant commenting on the Book of Mormon that basically, he found it boring, he found it insipid, he found it uninteresting, literarily, which I take offense to, because obviously, I think the Book of Mormon is beautiful. And so I'd love to push back on that idea that the Book of Mormon is chloroform imprint. He's coming, of course, from a literary English language, but the Book of Mormon is not English. We believe it is ancient, whether it is, you know, Hebrew, Egyptian, Joseph Smith's translation, all of that. And once you peel back those layers, it is gorgeous. And so one thing I loved is in the music session, it wasn't peeling back the ancient layers per se into, like, you know, what the original authors meant, but they were, you know, deriving new meaning from the Book of Mormon into beautiful artistry. And one example was this morning during the. Oh, gosh, I'm going to forget his name, Paul Anderson, when he was talking about all the different oratorios on the Book of Mormon. So he said that he highlighted a number of them, like leroy Robertsons from 1953, Robert Kundik from the 1970s. But he played Brett Stewart, who is one of the founders of millennial choirs the Messiah in America. And he talked about how in each of these oratorios, he's highlighting when Christ comes to America and, like, how they're doing that musically. And he highlights that when Christ came to America. In this particular oratorio, it talks about how it quotes the scripture, that I am Jesus Christ, I'm the light and light of the world. And musically, the melody goes upwards to kind of emphasize the world. And there's an appoggiatura. So there's this, like, note that's not part of the chord, that resolves into the chord to again, add this extra emphasis on world. Because this composer believes that the message of the Book of Mormon is far greater than any person given Jesus Christ. It's about the world. It is about how God loves his children and is saving the world. And as I was, like, listening to that presentation, it struck me that it reminds me a lot of chiasmus in that, you know, and Alma 36 is a famous example where a lot of people have pointed to there may be a chiastic structure in there. And for those who are not familiar, chiasm is a form of Hebrew ancient poetry where you have repeating forms or parallel lines that match each other in reverse order. So you go A, B, C, D, and then you reverse it. D, C, E, B, whatever. I can't spell backwards. But then. But. But usually in the chiasm, there's a turning point. The most important part is that centerpiece. And in Alma 36, that if you follow the Castic structure, it's. It's Jesus Christ. Alma the Younger is reflecting on his sins. And. But then he said, my mind caught hold upon Jesus Christ. And as I remembered Jesus Christ, I could remember my sins no more. And it just struck me that that's Very similar to kind of what these artists and musicians are doing musically. They're trying to come up with artistic ways to highlight the message of the Book of Mormon. Whether it's an ancient hebr. Ancient reformed Egyptian author trying to emphasize some kind of literary or theological message, or a musical artist trying to create something, it does the same thing, and it moves us. I mean, I. When Brother Anderson there was playing those. Those songs and those different glimpses, even though we just got excerpts like, I got chills listening to, like, the Messiah descending down. And that's really what it's all about. I love the scholarship. I love the history. But for me, it's, like, about what gives me my testimony of the Book of Mormon. Feeling that witness that this is God's word. So one question I have for you guys to kind of start us off is, is there a piece of art or music that has influenced your testimony of the Book of Mormon or moved you and you can't say chiasmus? I [00:05:55] Speaker C: can't say. Oh, man. Before I answer that, can I. Can we all agree that we need Neil to perform a solo from one of these oratorios? [00:06:04] Speaker B: You don't want him to do that? [00:06:05] Speaker C: You don't want to do that? No. [00:06:05] Speaker D: Okay, I promise. [00:06:08] Speaker C: No, that's fine. Let me talk about art. Perhaps Jasmine. So my wife is an artist, and when I married her, I like to feel that my. I'm not so much of a philistine anymore. Like, my sort of my artistic and aesthetic sensibilities. Right. A little bit. So I want to focus on some Book of Mormon art that I really like. There's two people in particular that have done very moving Book of Mormon art. I mean, of course, we have Walter Raine here, right. He's kind of the goat of Book of Mormon art, in some ways, at least contemporary Book of Mormon art. But moving beyond Walter Raine's work, which is great, the two guys really like are Jorge Coco. Everyone know Jorge Coco. You've seen his stuff. The Sacro Cubism. Great Book of Mormon art. He has a whole series of Book of Mormon art. Jorge Coco does. You can check out his website. And here in Provo, at the Compass Gallery, some of it's on display right now, as a matter of fact, which is kind of nice. And the second guy I want to shout out for Book of Mormon art is Godwin, the library of Godwin, our friend. He's [00:07:02] Speaker B: got some cool stuff. [00:07:02] Speaker C: Caleb Williams, AKA Godwin, he has for art history. People like art. Imagine if, like, Albrecht Durer and Gustave Dore had a baby who was a Latter Day Saint. That's Godwin, right? That's his style. That's his jam. And it's mine, too. I love it. So I can't name just one particular piece that has moved me necessarily beyond anything else. I think the work of these two artists has especially impacted me. As much as I love Arnold Freeberg, ladies and gentlemen, Arnold Freeberg is great for primary kids in the 1950s, when Cecil B. DeMille was still culturally relevant, because that's when he did this stuff. And it was for the children's magazine. I am glad to see that we have some movement beyond kind of this old epic style from Arnold Friedberg, that we have more sort of symbolic and expressionist, even impressionistic Book of Mormon art happening. And so that's great. So I want to highlight and shout out in terms of the artistic quality of Book of Mormon art, Jorge Coco and the Library of Godwin. Check them out. [00:08:04] Speaker B: Awesome. Neil. [00:08:06] Speaker D: Yeah, So I am probably the most. The least, I should say informed on art and whatnot here, but I actually, for a long time, one of my favorite chapters in the Book of Mormon, and probably a favorite of many others, is first, Nephi 11, with Nephi receiving the interpretation of his father's dream. And for many, many years, I've been struck by the association of the white tree that Lehi sees the Tree of Life with the Virgin holding the child that is made. And that association is made verbally with several of the clues in the text and things like that. And Dan Peterson has written about this and so on and so forth. And so for a long time, I wanted to see someone artistically represent the Virgin Mary holding the baby as the Tree of Life. And it's something that I've wanted to see for a long time. And I just. For whatever reason, I never. There doesn't seem to be a lot of art that does that. But one time, I think it might have been earlier this year, or maybe it was last year, we were up at the Church Museum. Church [00:09:19] Speaker B: History [00:09:19] Speaker D: Museum. Church History Museum. And we were looking at the art gallery that's upstairs and there was a depiction. For those of you who aren't aware, in the Arabic world they don't have art because it's kind of a taboo in the Islamic world to draw or illustrate things. And so they do this very kind of calligraphy style Arabic writing that they turn into images and pictures and things like that. And someone, I don't remember who the artist was, it was there at the Church History Library. Someone had done a translation of. I think it was a translation of the text of First Nephi 11 in an Arabic script that was designed to be the Tree of Life with the Virgin Mary represented in the tree as part of the tree. And I thought that was a beautiful, beautiful depiction of Nephi's vision there. A very creative. Something you do not expect to see when you're walking around the Church History museum. But I thought that was beautiful. And that's probably. That's what come to mind. That came to mind. [00:10:22] Speaker B: Well, for me, it was. I might, you know, date myself and be cringy, but testaments. The movie testaments. Let's [00:10:28] Speaker C: go [00:10:29] Speaker B: testaments. [00:10:29] Speaker C: All right. [00:10:30] Speaker B: I was a young girl when that film came out. But for me, you know, my. One of my earliest experiences being moved by the Book of Mormon and like feeling the spirit, feeling just deeply influenced by it, was not reading a paper by Jack Welch or a Brent Gardner book. It was seeing the narrative played out in that film and the music and the character driven narrative and the cinematography. It was all part of this work of art that deeply connected me to my savior in a way I hadn't experienced before and completely impacted me. And so I'm incredibly appreciative of the ways that art can derive meaning from the Book of Mormon and bless many lives. And I think that both artists and scholars can learn from each other a lot of ways, which is why I love this conference so much. I think sometimes scholars tend to maybe be. We love diving into the text. We love trying to find the original authorial meaning of what these ancient scripts were doing and what the literary and linguistic stuff was all doing. And so sometimes we can be dismissive of art that's not historically accurate or vice versa. Artists, you know, they have their passion, their vision, and maybe aren't as aware of some of the scholarship that can inform their art. And so I love when the two do come together, even though I know art is separate from scholarship and they serve different functions. But I love, like Emma Earle, who was highlighted at this conference. She created this new reimagining of the 10 virgins based on research that she had learned from the Messages of Christ YouTube channel. And. Thank you. [00:12:04] Speaker C: Yeah. Emma and I had a chat yesterday about some of her work and she said, I'd be. I want to do some book Mormon art. So let's collaborate, get some scholarly insight into my art. I want to do so not to brag for myself, but just to say yes, like, conferences like this are important for that very reason. [00:12:19] Speaker D: Well, and what I think, though, is while art and scholarship are different things, I think the reason why it's powerful to bring them together in a conference like this is because when it comes to the Book of Mormon for Latter Day Saints, for believers like us, both are forms of consecration. Right. When you use your time and your talents, whatever those talents are. I do not have artistic talents, and so you don't want me using those talents in that particular way, but I can research and I can write and I can do things. When you choose to use your time and talents to help people better understand, better connect with, better relate to the Book of Mormon, that's consecration right there. Right. And whether you're an artist, whether you're a scholar, whether you're a podcaster, whatever you are, it's great to bring all the people who want to consecrate their time and talents to helping people deepen their connection to the Book of Mormon, bringing them all together in one place, I think that's a powerful thing. [00:13:14] Speaker C: Jasmine, may I ask you, who is your favorite character on the Testaments and why is it the monkey? Papa. The Messiah's here, right? Isn't that what his name is? [00:13:24] Speaker D: Yes. [00:13:24] Speaker B: If I had a nickel for every time I said, you are a specter from the gods, I would be rich. It's a meme. But to go back to Emma Earle, it's not that understanding or incorporating some new historical act aspect diminished the artistic expression at all because, you know, she won best in Show. Like, clearly the art still had a ton of merit. And like your own wife, Stephen, Amberly is an artist and she incorporates a lot of symbolic art in her work, which I can only assume is very influenced by you being her husband. [00:13:53] Speaker C: It may be a little bit, yeah. [00:13:55] Speaker B: But I love seeing when those two come together, even though, you know, very. Taking artistic liberties has its own place as well. I do love when I can see both of those interweave with each other. And it's just. It's a lot of fun. So obviously our passion is more on the scholarship side of things. So we really loved the sessions yesterday. So I want to bring up a criticism I see of the Book of Mormon that the use of seer stones in the Book of Mormon interpreters in the Book of Mormon is a sure sign that it's actually 19th century fiction, that Joseph Smith made this up, because the use of seer stones and magic rocks is this reflection of Joseph Smith's own 19th century worldview. So, Neil, what do you think we can say to that, based on what we Heard at the conference this weekend. [00:14:43] Speaker D: Yeah. Well, I think Kerry Hole yesterday pretty definitively drove the stake right into the heart of that idea. I mean, that was [00:14:52] Speaker C: R.I.P. d Michael Quinn and his book from the 80s. [00:14:56] Speaker D: That presentation from Kerry yesterday was an absolute tour de force on the use of Sears and scrying instruments. From mirrors to stones to all kinds of things, not just among. And you know, it was breathtaking how well he was able to just go through the entire double continent of the Americas from Alaska to I don't know how far south he got in South America. [00:15:22] Speaker C: Pierre del Fuego, [00:15:23] Speaker D: the [00:15:24] Speaker C: tip of Chile or [00:15:24] Speaker D: something. Yeah, he's the whole continent. Just talking about all of these different practices. And he went from nearly 3000 BC to right up into pretty contemporary times. Yeah, [00:15:36] Speaker C: like people he has met personally indigenous are still doing this. [00:15:40] Speaker D: Yeah, absolutely. And it was stunning. And as he went through and he showed all the different ways and the features, what they used these stones for in virtually every aspect. You looked at that and you said, hey, that's what's going on in Mosiah 8. That's what's going on in Ether 3. That's how seers stones and Sears work in the Book of Mormon. And so that was. I thought that was pretty remarkable. And he also showed that, you know, and his argument was that, that even the folk magic practices of Joseph Smith's time were actually probably influenced some by indigenous cultures. Well, [00:16:14] Speaker C: as I understand, and somebody in the comments later can double check me here, but isn't one of the seer stones Joseph Smith possessed? It was an Indian gorget or something? The Whitmers? I think it was either Joseph or the Whitmers. Somebody close to the Book of Mormon translation possessed. And you've seen pictures that's through like little drill holes in it. It's like a little kind of rectangular looking stone. It's an Indian gorget. It's a Native American seer stone, basically. Yeah. [00:16:36] Speaker D: So. Well, and he talked about the pouches. Right. And that, you know, Joseph Smith had a pouch that he kept it in. That's an indigenous practice. The practice of storing them in little caches in boxes, which is where you get the Urim and Thummim. Right. It's in the stone box with the plates and the other items. This is something he didn't. Carey didn't bring this up. But this is something I came across in my reading once in a book by Alan Christensen, who's also up at byu, is when the. See when the tower to the chapel was being built or the cathedral in Santiago, Atitlan, was being built. The indigenous Maya groups there in the area, they put little cache boxes of stone boxes in the foundations of each of the corners. And in those boxes, when it was excavated later, they found obsidian, pieces of obsidian that were identified by a shaman, a local shaman, as seer stones. And they were triangular in shape, which is interesting if you know the Lucy Mack Smith account describing the Urim and Thummim as three pointed diamonds. So I thought that was kind of cool. And they're in a stone box just like the Urim of Thummim stored, right? [00:17:48] Speaker C: Yeah. I think seer stones get a lot of derision and mockery in the contemporary world, especially from former members of the church, who thinks it's all really silly and dumb. Informed saints, ladies and gentlemen, we are a pro Seer Stones podcast. We did an episode on seer stones discussing their use with Garrett Darkmatt. In fact, it was our first episode, wasn't it, with Garrett Dirkmaat, BYU historian on Joseph Smith's use of seer stones. I just want the record to show that if you are mocking seer stones or the idea of seer stones, you are literally mocking centuries of indigenous culture. This thing is so prevalent in the world that the Book of Mormon comes from, both anciently and contemporary. We're not saying you have to believe seer stones or whatever. Okay, fine. But maybe have a little cultural sensitivity towards why so many people across so many different cultures do put a lot of value in these sorts of things. So I really appreciated Carrie's research on that regard, showing that even contemporary Maya shaman and others are still using these things. Right. The example he gave of one guy using, like, a Coke bottle as his seer stone, that's pretty great, right? I have a can of Coke right here. Maybe I could make it a seer stone. I don't know. [00:18:51] Speaker B: Revelation on the [00:18:52] Speaker C: spot. Yeah, no, it was great. Right? So, yeah, I agree with you, Neil. Lots of great stuff from Kerry's paper there. [00:18:56] Speaker B: Yeah. And I mean, the idea of mocking seer stones in this folk magic isn't new. I mean, even in Joseph Smith's day, it was receiving this mockery and derision from a lot of people. I mean, his. From what I understand, and I'm learning about this recently, Stephen was helping me. His 1826 trial was about his use of seer stones. And, you know, in the documents we have, the. The judge notated this case is like, oh, Joseph Smith, the glass looker. And, you know, people were persecuting you know, mocking, making fun of Joseph Smith because he was participating in this old folk practice. But again, it's, it's deeply indigenous [00:19:28] Speaker C: and it's tied to the Book of Mormon. I've even seen some Latter Day Saints call this. They're just like a bunch of dumb rocks or something, right? It's like, no, no, no, guys. Like, this is an important part of our history, our religious history and tradition, both with Joseph Smith in the Book of Mormon itself. So, yeah, not to belabor the point, but lots of really great. I'm [00:19:45] Speaker B: going to belabor the point once more. Okay, [00:19:47] Speaker C: good [00:19:47] Speaker B: point. In addition, the presentation before Kerry Hole Biggerstaff was talking about divination in the Bible. And so again, like, if you're going to be mocking seer stones as this way to receive Revelation, I mean, we've also got to compare it to the biblical tradition. And maybe you dismiss the Bible as fiction too. But if you are a Christian, if you're a Jew, if you're a believer in these biblical texts, you have seriously, that at least ancient Israelites took very seriously alternate forms of divination, whether it was the biblical High Priest Urim and Thummim, which was some kind of divine lot where he'd cast stones to receive Revelation, or Joseph of Egypt has a cup where he is divining things that he frames his brother Benjamin with. I mean, there's a number of instances where characters are not being condemned for using various ways to receive revelation and interact with God. So, yeah, [00:20:34] Speaker C: my favorite is when King Saul goes to the seer Samuel to find his lost donkeys. Like, that's totally crazy. Why would people use a seer to look for lost things? Right? Like that's. That thing Joseph Smith did was, you know, evil or satanic or whatever. Except, oh, wait, that's right. It's also in the Bible. Like, go read the story. I think it's what, 1st Samuel 10 or something. The way Samuel picks Saul to be the prophet, the way Samuel meets him is Saul says, hey, we know you're a seer. We lost my dad's donkeys. Can you help us find. He says, don't worry about the donkeys. You're going to be the king of Israel. Right? So it's, you know, different priorities. So, yeah, it's thoroughly rooted in the biblical tradition, in Mesoamerican and North American, South American tradition. It's not just a 19th century Folk magic thing, ladies and gentlemen. It's not anachronistic of the Book of Mormon and Carrie's paper Hit a home run, I think. [00:21:19] Speaker B: Okay, so let's talk a little bit about the session yesterday morning. So this was the session you presented in, but we're not going to talk about your paper. Stephen, we've already. [00:21:28] Speaker C: Best paper. Come on. Just kidding. [00:21:31] Speaker B: I'd be interested to hear you guys thoughts on Alan Hanson's paper. He spoke on the interaction between Deuteronomy and the Book of Mormon. And this has been a. Been a topic of conversation that's come up recently. A lot of people want to try to push back on how influential Deuteronomy was on the Book of Mormon or how much they're pushing back on it, et cetera. Stephen, what are your thoughts? [00:21:49] Speaker C: Well, before I begin, I'll just shout out this book because Alan mentioned it, but he didn't mention the title of his paper. So it's in this book, Open Thou Mine Eyes Defending the Old Testament in Latter Day Saint Doctrine. Neil and I both have papers in here. Alan has his paper in here. [00:22:05] Speaker D: My [00:22:06] Speaker C: wife took the COVID art. But that's not why I'm highlighting it. I'm highlighting it. I mean, I kind of am a little bit citing it because Alan's paper in here is chapter four Defending Josiah. And Alan mentioned it in his remarks. So I thought I would plug it for our friend Jared Riddick here who's manning the fair booth. So you can go grab a copy of this at the fair booth. So here's what Alan says about this, both in this paper and in the one he did yesterday. Certainly we're not saying that the Book of Mormon just like is beat for beat Deuteronomy. Right. That there are no tensions with Deuteronomy. Neil has published on this how. [00:22:38] Speaker B: Yeah, you have your own paper where you kind of interact with this dialogue. [00:22:42] Speaker C: Yeah, this idea. So certainly, like, you know, there are some places where the Book of Mormon is in tension with the Book of Deuteronomy or some aspects of the Book of Deuteronomy, centralization of worship and sacrifice and things like that, you know, but this, this claim that like, well, the Book of Mormon is anti Deuteronomy or it was meant to like in some of the more kind of extreme formulations of the theory, like the Book of Mormon was like providentially preserved and put forth to combat the evil falsehoods of Deuteronomy that it was going to perpetuate or something like that. Right. I think Allen has very effectively ref. He shows pretty effectively, I think, that the authors of the Book of Mormon, the prophets of the Book of Mormon. They are heavily influenced by the terminology of Deuteronomy, the concepts from Deuteronomy, the overarching theological and historical methods of the Book of Deuteronomy. And the Deuteronomistic school. Yeah, Deuteronomy, sort of. Broadly. I have just a few notes. I won't be too exhaustive here, but Grant Hardy, in his Oxford edition of the Book of Mormon that came out two or three years ago, which I recommend, he has a ton of notes on how the Book of Mormon interacts with biblical texts, including Deuteronomy. Here's some of the things that Grant Hardy notices. The idea that there would be a prophet like unto Moses quoted in 1st Nephi and Mosiah 13. Guys, that's Deuteronomy 18, right? This prophecy of the prophet like unto Moses that the New Testament also quotes, that's from the Deuteronomy. The rule of two or three witnesses that we love to cite. Book of Mormon cites that we cited today. That's a Deuteronomy thing. But you need two or three witnesses to adjudicate, sort of in the context of Deuteronomy. Legal stuff for the Book of Mormon. It's like witnesses for Christ or whatever. Choose life or choose death. This is Lehi to his kids. Right. In second Nephi 2, you have these two ways before you kids choose one or the other. That is textbook. Almost a direct echo and allusion to Moses in Deuteronomy. [00:24:27] Speaker D: And I was just going to add to that. I mean, that's part of the broader context. There is. Noel Reynolds has talked about how Lehi's entire Last Testament there is structured like and patterned after Moses's final speeches in Deuteronomy. Right? [00:24:43] Speaker C: Yep. Hardy notices that as well. [00:24:46] Speaker B: I tend to think of like the famous Book of Mormon. If ye keep my commandments, ye shall prosper in the land. Isn't that a Deuteronomy? [00:24:53] Speaker C: Absolutely it is. That's all through Deuteronomy 28:30. [00:24:56] Speaker D: That's the essential core idea of Deuteronomy. Distilled into like two sentences, right? [00:25:01] Speaker C: Yes. No, literally. Right. So I mean, the covenant language, they will be cut off from the land or cut off from the presence of the Lord. That's Deuteronomy language. You get the point, ladies and gentlemen. I don't have to give more examples. I will give one more actually, because it's important. Kings. Kingship. We talked about kings. Aaron Pond yesterday mentioned democracy versus kingship or whatever. Book of Mormon is kind of ambivalent about kings. Right. Everybody like Kings, are they good, are they bad? That's an ambivalence that Deuteronomy shares and the way they kind of structure it. Good kings are Benjamin and Mosiah because it says they follow, quote, the statutes and the commandments and the, you know, the laws of the Lord or whatever. Like it's Mosiah 5 or 6. It says about Mosiah, he followed in the ways of the Lord, his statutes, his commandments, Deuteronomy language, guys. Who comes next? King Noah. He's a bad king. Why is he a bad king? He violates all the tenets of Deuteronomy. He taxes people, he builds big palaces, he has lots of wives and concubines. You go down the list of all the violations of what kings aren't supposed to do in Deuteronomy, and King Noah does that. So it's playing with that as well. [00:26:02] Speaker D: Yeah. Taylor Halverson actually wrote a paper that was published in Interpreter where he actually goes through and shows that, like, basically all good kings in the Book of Mormon comply to the standard of a king in Deuteronomy. The bad kings, Noah, the Jaredite kings, they all violate those standards. And the entire Book of Mosiah. You could basically chalk up to a polemic about kingship that uses Deuteronomy. Right. As its kind of. As its source, as its foil, if you will. Yeah. [00:26:31] Speaker C: So, yeah, more we could say about that, but I'll just summarize by saying Alan Hansen, I thought, did a terrific job of pushing back against. I'm sure it's well meaning and sincere in some way, but I think it's really misguided to have this weird, like, new anti Deuteronomy bias I see from some church members. Again, there's plenty of conversation to have about where does it conflict with some biblical stuff, including Deuteronomy. That's fine. But to go so far as to say the Book of Mormon's like anti Deuteronomy or something, I just don't think that's at all feasible. I don't think that holds up at all. [00:27:01] Speaker B: I mean, I think it's a fascinating path of inquiry. I think it's great that people are asking these kinds of questions. Like, yes, I think that's part of, of taking the Book of Mormon seriously and critically is saying, oh, I am noticing some patterns here. Let's dig deeper. Is there a layer that we can peel back that maybe the book morons in tension with some things? And like you said, Neil's written a paper on this and Alan's written a paper, but ultimately we want to also not throw the baby out with the bathwater. There's plenty of conversations that can be had. But I mean, Jesus Christ himself, when he comes down in Third Nephi, I'm pretty sure he quotes Deuteronomy then, too, [00:27:32] Speaker C: and in the New Testament. [00:27:34] Speaker B: So Christ himself doesn't seem to be terribly opposed to Deuteronomy. [00:27:37] Speaker D: So one thing that Alan mentioned that I thought was really useful and an important observation is, and I don't know, there's a lot of context, I think that you need to really understand this observation. But he noted that the Book of Mormon is both. Deuteron. Dang it. [00:27:53] Speaker C: Deuteronomistic. [00:27:54] Speaker D: It's that. And it also draws on Zion theology. And if you're familiar with biblical studies, you know that these are often pitted. Like, these are often understood by biblical scholars as competing theological schools within. So [00:28:08] Speaker B: what is Zion theology? [00:28:10] Speaker D: Zion theology is this idea that Jerusalem is Zion and the kingship. It's also really strongly connected to the Davidic King, the idea that the Davidic King would never fall. He would rule forever in Jerusalem. Jerusalem would never fall. These kinds of ideas are associated with what's called Zion theology. And this is often considered to be in tension with Deuteronomy. The [00:28:35] Speaker C: Deuteronomy, [00:28:37] Speaker D: because it comes with this more conditional promise. Right. Whereas, like the promise to David was that he would reign and rule forever in his lineage and so forth. [00:28:46] Speaker B: Whereas in Deuteronomy, if you keep my commandments, you will prosper. [00:28:49] Speaker D: Right? Yeah. And Alan notes that actually the Book of Mormon is blending elements from both of these. And you also see the antagonists in the Book of Mormon, say Laman and Lemuel also are blending both of these. Who didn't think Jerusalem could fall? That's a Zion theology idea. Right. And that's Laman and Lemuel. So the Book of Mormon. I'm very struck by how much the Book of Mormon really does reflect and tap into what were important theological debates going on in ancient Israel in the 7th century BC specifically. But it doesn't cut a clean line straight through. It mixes both of these different theologies together. And you see how different interpretations and different things, things from both of those theologies are being melded, because that's where you find the truth. Right. [00:29:38] Speaker C: I'll just point out real quick before we move on. Real quick, at the back of Hardy's Oxford edition of the Book of Mormon, he has a section, Biblical Quotations, Allusions and Verbal Parallels. We got lots of Genesis We've got lots of Exodus. That makes sense. They talk about the Exodus all the time in the Red Sea and whatever. We've got some numbers from like, you know, the bronze snake that they love. They're obsessed with that bronze snake that Moses sets up in the. That's from Numbers. And then we've got like a page and a half or so or almost a page of Deuteronomy quotations and allusions. And then you hop over and the next big ones are like Psalms and Isaiah. Go figure. Right. So [00:30:12] Speaker D: those are. Those are Deuteronomy Psalms and Isaiah are also the three most cited or quoted in the Dead Sea Scrolls. And [00:30:18] Speaker C: in the New Testament. And [00:30:19] Speaker D: in the New Testament. [00:30:20] Speaker C: Yeah. So you see some continuity there. So something to consider. Go check out Alan Hanson's work and Grant Hardy's as a complement to that. [00:30:27] Speaker B: Okay, so what about. I know a passion of yours, Neil, is Nephite timekeeping. You've written a paper on like how Mayan Bach tunes, Ho tunes cartoons might be influential in the Book of Mormon. And also Brant Gardner spoke on this a little bit. Now, we had Brant on our show just right the day before the conference. And [00:30:48] Speaker D: so we recorded with him. It hasn't come out. [00:30:50] Speaker B: It hasn't come out yet. But he ended up touching on a lot of things that he did in this conference in that episode. It was a lot of fun. We didn't quite touch on the Nephite timekeeping stuff, but I do find mind calendrics fascinating. So we had Scott, Brian gave a presentation on the timekeeping. What were your thoughts on that one? [00:31:07] Speaker D: I thought he. He did a great job. And what I thought something that he did that I think we need to do more of is he paid attention to how things shift and change in the Book of Mormon over time. Right. We've got to stop thinking about Nephites and Lamanites and Book of Mormon peoples in this static way, as if they're just the same and their tendencies and their practices and even their theological beliefs necessarily are stagnant. This is a thousand year society. And then the Jaredites are something else entirely. Right. And so he paid attention to how certain things change over time, particularly how their sense of time changes over time. And he kind of argued that you see maybe a little bit more of an Israelite way of thinking about time earlier on in the Book of Mormon. And he paid attention. You know, Mark Twain didn't like. And it came to pass. He paid attention to how. And it came to pass and its partner phrase and it shall come to pass. He paid attention to how those are used in the text and function. And this is something Brandt has talked a lot about is how, how that functions in the text. But he kind of tracked it through time in the text and kind of argued that, hey, as it gets more and more into the new world, we see, see the new world tendencies of how this is used and stuff show up more and the old world weighs a little less. And he did this. [00:32:31] Speaker B: It's an impressive thing for Joseph Smith to keep track of. Well, [00:32:33] Speaker D: it. And [00:32:34] Speaker B: you see it linguistically too. I mean, at the beginning you've got. Nephi says we're writing in the learning of the Jews, the language of the Egyptians. By the end it's reformed Egyptian. And you assume that means there's like an evolution of the language going on. [00:32:44] Speaker D: Oh yeah, absolutely. And this is something that, like I said, he, we need to do a lot more of this. We need to be paying attention to how things are different from Nephi to Jacob to the Book of Mosiah and Alma and Helaman and on and on because it's not a static society and I don't think they remain static. And so I really appreciated that he showed how some of these Mayan timekeeping things start to show up more in the later parts of the Book of Mormon. [00:33:13] Speaker B: Cool. I'm going to give a shout out to Julie Frederick's talk because I thought her presentation was really interesting talking about the different between how Lamanite women are treated in the text versus Nephite women. And I remember something very similar being argued by Joseph Spencer a number of years ago. And so I'd have to like go back and see exactly like the nuances of their different arguments. But I do love that we're paying close attention to the women in the Book of Mormon because we usually just have the throwaway phrase of like, oh, there's only like six women in the Book of Mormon. It's. And a lot of people have questions about that. Why aren't women being paid attention to? Why is it so male dominated? And I mean, one answer is that it's a mark of antiquity. I think if this were in 19th century century text, we probably would see a lot more women. But it's, it's a, a lineage history. And I mean generally it was, you know, this is a record from father to son to father to son to father to son. And so the focus is on those record keepers. But I love that she did still draw out, we have things in the text that we can learn from Lamanite women, Nephite women. And often the way the Lamanites are treating their women is better than the way the. The way that the Nephites are treating their women, women. [00:34:18] Speaker D: Well, I mean, one of the things that, honestly, I liked about her presentation is, for one thing, there's more women in the Book of Mormon than you think. That was something that kind of came. That came out for me at least from her presentation. And I liked actually how she highlighted some of the Lamanite queens that you maybe don't realize are actually having quite the influence. When she talked about how Amalakiah, he has the king assassinated, but then he goes and he shows a lot of deference to the queen and there's things he does to win her over. And, you know, he marries her, which is part of how he establishes his legitimacy. But that goes to speak to how important she was and things like that. I thought, you know, I'd never thought about that before, [00:35:03] Speaker B: or how the servants are obeying the queen, even though they might be the king's servants, not her servants. Yeah. Just think little nuances I hadn't noticed. And she even, you know, makes the comment that maybe, maybe, you know, the way that the Nephites were treating their women contributed to God's justice and the destruction of the Nephites. And. And I've seen other people make similar arguments that, like, oh, if you look at the text, the way they're treating their women was clearly the reason that God destroyed them. Or. But then you can also insert your. Your own pet topic, like, oh, it was because of the racism. Oh, it was because of the violence. And so you got to be careful to, you know, not go too far. And I don't think Julie does that, but I think the answer is also yes, it's all of those reasons led to Nephi destruction. It is the way that they were not keeping the commandments of the Lord, which include way you are treating your wives, the way you are treating people who are other than you, all contributes to God's destruction of the. [00:35:50] Speaker C: I can't remember if Julie touched on her or not. Forgive me, I can't remember the comments there, but did she discuss Morianton's maidservant yesterday? It was mostly on the queens. Right? Yeah. [00:36:00] Speaker D: I don't remember her talking about the Morientin. [00:36:02] Speaker C: Yeah. But basically, you know, this unnamed servant girl, she, like, saves the Nephites from, like, because the idea is Morianton, she turns [00:36:12] Speaker D: tide. [00:36:12] Speaker C: Yeah. He's a Nephite defector. Who's going to open up a second front in the north or whatever, but they're able to head it off and stop it because he abuses this maidservant of his and she hightails it and tells Moroni all about it, like she's a hero. Yeah, right. Like, that's fantastic. So, yeah, I'm glad that there's more work like this being done too, Jasmine, for sure. [00:36:31] Speaker B: So kind of bringing this all together. Where do we think Book of Mormon scholarship is going to go in the future? And I know Rosalind Welch touched on this a little bit in her key note. [00:36:42] Speaker C: I loved that little picture that Rosalind Welch had of, like, the Bible on, like, a dissecting table and people taking an X acto knife. Like, it does kind of feel like that sometimes. And we have to be careful. We don't want to do that. I see the future Book of Mormon scholarship going into interdisciplinary and sort of comparative studies. Right. So we've seen some of this on display, especially yesterday, bringing both the Old and New World perspectives into dialogue with each other at the same time. Carrie Hull and I have at least published one or two pieces now kind of doing this. We're working on another one right now. So I'm really encouraged to see this interdisciplinary approach. I love Hugh Nibley, of course, you know, we stand on the shoulders of Hugh Nibley and Sidney Sperry, but they did all Old World stuff. They were trained in Bible in the Near East. Right. They never really touched Mesoamerica or New World Perspectives or whatever. So I was really pleased to see a lot of presenters here, Carrie, Mark Brandt, others who. Who were casting a wider net to bring in more comparative data and cultural comparative data to make our Book of Mormon come to life. So I see a lot of exciting things developing on that score. [00:37:48] Speaker D: Yeah. And I actually, I liked how much there was of New World perspectives being brought in, ancient New World perspectives being brought in, and how many people we had talking about that. I think that there's been a little bit of a lull in that kind of work. You know, Brandt put out his book Traditions of the fathers in 2015. There haven't really been any major works in that area for a while. And so I'm hoping that this and some other trends that I'm seeing are a sign of maybe a bit of a renaissance in New World perspectives on the Book of Mormon. [00:38:24] Speaker B: Well, I can only imagine that some of that reticence comes from like, okay, well, we don't know where the Book of Mormon took place. The Church doesn't take a position on it officially. And so people don't want to be presumptuous or you know, combative about the geography. But at the same time, like, look at all the cool things we've learned about the Book of Mormon over this weekend because we were willing to at least like, okay, take a hypothetical, if it takes place here, what can we learn about the Book of Mormon text? And I like that just fires me up. I love feeling like I understand who Nephi is better and who Moroni is better because of the culture that they lived in and breathed. So I, I, I agree. I would love to see more of this just to see what can we, we learn. [00:39:01] Speaker C: I just think so long as it doesn't elevate to the status of a dogma, like my geography theory is the revealed official true theory or whatever. Right. Like, and put it on par with the scriptures themselves. As long as we have a humility and we're open to other possibilities and seeing evidence in different ways. And yeah, I say full steam ahead on these sorts of studies for sure. [00:39:21] Speaker D: But another thing that I think this conference helps exemplify is, is as far as the future goes, is just really kind of broadening the kind of people and the kind of disciplines that are being used to engage the text in the first place. You know, yesterday we had a lot of what you might traditionally expect, the ancient, you know, the Egyptologist here, the people with ancient biblical and ancient New World sorts of perspectives. But today we had a rocket scientist tell us what he gets out of the Book of Mormon. And you know, my dad actually was a, was an engineer growing up. And I sitting through that one, I thought, you know, this, this feels like family home, evening lessons. When I was growing up, like, that was, that was the way my dad taught and thought about stuff. And so, you know, I thought that was, I thought that was great. A few months ago at the fair conference, I talked about, I actually put a slide up that showed a whole bunch of different disciplines and I talked about how the study of the Book of Mormon, to really take it seriously, it has to be interdisciplinary. And we need people from so many different backgrounds, grounds, so many different walks of life, taking, consecrating themselves. Like I talked about earlier, taking this book seriously and saying, how do I, as an architect, as, as a [00:40:36] Speaker B: biologist, as [00:40:37] Speaker D: a biologist, as a rocket scientist. We had an archivist talking about it yesterday. How do I, what do I get out of the Book of Mormon when I bridge, bring what I know from my professional or academic or maybe it's even just a hobbyist sort of expertise that you have in something. What do I get out of this? And then how can I share that with the world? How can I help other people make those connections who don't have that same background that I do? I think we need that. And the future of Book of Mormon studies. It's got to be interdisciplinary like this. It's got to bring all these perspectives together. And again, that's another reason why I just love what this conference is. Is doing. [00:41:15] Speaker B: Well said. Any final thoughts? Well, remember, guys, you can study deeply and believe boldly. And thank you for having us today.

Other Episodes

Episode 21

February 09, 2026 • 00:35:52
Episode Cover

Abraham’s Story Is the Temple Endowment in Disguise (Jeff Bradshaw Explains)

The restored gospel didn’t “start” in 1830, it’s ancient, and Abraham’s story is one of the clearest windows into the covenant pathway and temple...

Listen

Episode 2

September 21, 2025 • 01:03:42
Episode Cover

Seer Stones and the Miracle of Book of Mormon Translation

Was Joseph Smith’s use of seer stones evidence of superstition — or of divine power?   In this episode of Informed Saints, hosts Jasmin Rappleye,...

Listen

Episode 6

October 19, 2025 • 00:43:28
Episode Cover

Polygamy Denial Debunked: A Look At The Primary Sources

What do the actual documents say about Nauvoo-era plural marriage? In this episode, we walk through the primary sources behind the claims—reading what was...

Listen